RSS Feed

Peter Lewis: Property and tax

Thursday, March 31, 2016

A reply to those who claim investors have a tax advantage by APIA Vice President Peter Lewis:

Consider the analogy of a Motel owner verses a Residential Landlord.

The Motel owner rents accommodation by the night.
The Landlord rents accommodation by the month or by the year.
The Motel owner is in business. As such, he is required to pay income tax on any profit (his rental income minus his costs) he makes renting out rooms. 
The Landlord is in business. As such he is required to pay tax on any profit (his rental income minus his costs)he makes renting out houses.
Both pay tax at normal income rates on this profit.
Both have no tax advantage over any other business or private homeowner.
When the motel owner finally decides he has had enough, he sells the motel land and buildings.
When the landlord decides he has had enough he sells his housing land and buildings.
In both cases, there is no tax payable on any gain in the land and buildings if he should sell them at a higher price than what he initially paid to buy them.
In both cases there is no tax deduction available should they sell the land and buildings for less than they paid to buy them. (e.g. if they bought in Tokoroa or Galatea).
However . . .
If the motel owner is in the business of developing, renovating, or buying and selling motels with the intention of making a profit then he is not in business as a motel operator, he is in the buying and selling property business.
If house owner is in the business of developing, renovating, or buying and selling houses with the intention of making a profit then he is not in business as a landlord, he is in the buying and selling property business.
In both cases, they are then liable to pay tax at normal income rates on the profit they make from buying and selling property less their expenses in doing so.
The confusion lies in identifying exactly what type business the property person is carrying out - landlording or property trading. They are both taxed, but in different ways.

Recent Posts


privacy minor dwelling productivity Jeff Bezos off the plan winz Landlording ird first home buying daikin heating bond form warren buffett trespass bankruptcy debt enforcement partners income legal cost anz finance interest deductibility buying rules cgt brightline heat pump structure election2020 renovation re agent rta property management positive cash flow DTI Gluckman bad tenant khh equity property cycle skill shortage Zodiak Management inspection asbestos landlord CCC rent sale and purchase capital gain ring-fencing interest limitation covid-19 interest rates opes partners short term rental rental wof robert kiyosaki interest only television bond Must know parry v inglis maintenance Market report relationship Editor's Choice reserve bank LIM subdivision tenancy tribunal Kris Pedersen Mortgages and Insurance return lvr ocr worksafe Case study tenancy issues Property (Relationships) Act property apprentice Standards New Zealand advice letting fee p lab beginner investor HHGA speculator termination watercare nzpif meth rent control auckland council letting rta reform barfoot and thompson property maintenance mindset insulation fixed-term tenancy mortgage initio buyer's agent retaliatory notice tenancy services management HSWA shortland chartered accountants data security property business election 2017 financial advisers act gluckman report Investor story Q&A water bill heater trust travel bubble will RTAA 2019 development market property value housing bubble shower dome personal growth Tribunal case study buying CoreLogic RBNZ housing package rent increase meth contamination building insurance sublease rental market airbnb negotiation twg report HHS banking tenant wins warm up new zealand smoke alarm investment strategy house prices rtaa2020 yield Must knows sale and purchas anti-social behaviour Investment tip kiwibuild Level 4 principal and interest inflation unitary plan quiet enjoyment apia early termination wealth creation cash-flow TCIT Sponsored post investor Keith Hay Homes rent arrears auckland legal extractor fan Question and answer Holler boarding house government scotney williams commerce commission recycling equity education lockdown ventilation debt to income short-term rental How to market rent clnz trademe damage ask an expert cat Guest blog holiday house housing affordability tax


Introducing Our Partners
Principal Sponsor - Kris Pedersen Mortgages & Insurance logo Gold Sponsor - Barfoot & Thompson logo Gold Sponsor - CoreLogic logo Property Apprentice logo The Insulation Warehouse logo The Renovation Team logo The New Zealand Property Investors' Federation logo