RSS Feed

Kelvin Davidson: Our ‘top down’ perspective on the Government’s investor tax policy changes

Tuesday, April 27, 2021


It’s an understatement to suggest that the content of the Government’s housing policy announcement on 23rd March was a surprise to most. In reality, it was a major surprise to all. However, now that the dust has settled a bit, our perception is that the changes won’t have as much impact as first thought. Sure, some landlords will look to sell properties and/or raise rents sharply, but for the most part, we think people will carry on, just a bit less profitably than before.


Our analysis boils down to three key points:

  • Existing landlords are unlikely to sell en masse over the next few years. After all, the full brunt of the removal of interest deductibility won’t be felt until 2025/26, and only by those with large mortgages. Then we also need to keep in mind that the cheapest option for many investors from a tax perspective is still going to be to avoid Brightline by not selling. And finally, there’s still the thorny issue of what to do with any sale proceeds anyway.
  • Rents are unlikely to rise noticeably more sharply than they would have done anyway. First, if there’s no big landlord sell-off, then the supply of rental stock will be similar. Second, the historical evidence suggests that rents are much more closely tied to tenants’ incomes than landlords’ costs – for example, previous law changes (such as depreciation removal and Healthy Homes) haven’t caused rents to spike across the board. And of course many landlords value a good tenant and want to avoid vacancies.
  • But further investor purchases of existing properties from here on will be curtailed. The extension of the Brightline Test to 10 years for purchases of existing properties and the instant loss of interest deductibility incentivise investors to shift their focus more towards new-builds (which of course are also exempt from the loan to value ratio speed limits).

Now it’s important to note that those views reflect a top-down, aggregate perspective – but we also acknowledge that some individual landlords will of course follow a different path, and that’s understandable. We had already heard anecdotally that some long-time residential landlords had started to question whether they had the time/inclination anymore, so that might be a cohort looking at their options – especially if interest rates were to rise over an 18-24 month horizon.

Finally, looking out five or 10 years, it’s uncertain how these regulations might impact the market, but we suspect that property will still be a chosen path by many. They’ll just look at other ways to make property ‘stack up’, which of course could include paying less in the first place than they otherwise would have done. In addition, for new landlords 10 years down the track, they may never know that interest deductibility even existed, so it just won’t be a factor them.


This is a guest blog submission from Kelvin Davidson from CoreLogic NZ. Guest submissions are a way for APIA members to share their views and experiences with each other and do not necessarily reflect the views and position of the APIA.  The content of this article is general in nature and not intended as a substitute for specific professional advice on any matters and should not be relied upon for that purpose.


Kelvin Davidson

Kelvin is the Chief Property Economist of CoreLogic NZ. Prior to joining CoreLogic, Kelvin spent 15 years working in private sector economic consultancies in NZ and the UK, and he is well practised in applying macroeconomic trends and data to the property market.


Recent Posts


property management ask an expert banking ird income nzpif mortgage Zodiak Management cash-flow letting asbestos off the plan daikin reserve bank property maintenance unitary plan smoke alarm CCC khh housing package Landlording warren buffett advice return Market report sale and purchas positive cash flow privacy trademe interest rates ventilation insulation rent sublease airbnb letting fee cgt bad tenant personal growth property value gluckman report government auckland council Question and answer maintenance rental wof cat interest limitation property bankruptcy wins Must know shortland chartered accountants Level 4 Gluckman tenant holiday house business robert kiyosaki retaliatory notice early termination first home buying productivity warm up new zealand RBNZ yield Jeff Bezos market Guest blog negotiation tax short term rental mindset legal rta reform legal cost trust HHGA apia property apprentice re agent landlord TCIT travel bubble education anz kiwibuild Investment tip Investor story relationship election 2017 interest only short-term rental ring-fencing opes partners wealth creation Sponsored post lvr investor inflation debt to income fixed-term tenancy principal and interest Standards New Zealand equity rtaa2020 meth contamination meth boarding house commerce commission data security extractor fan tenancy tribunal barfoot and thompson election2020 heat pump buying rules debt enforcement Case study LIM house prices capital gain tenancy issues tenancy services How to partners market rent Kris Pedersen Mortgages and Insurance rent increase recycling equity housing affordability p lab property cycle finance heating brightline anti-social behaviour will Property (Relationships) Act initio buyer's agent minor dwelling speculator twg report damage inspection interest deductibility insurance Holler skill shortage rent arrears management clnz shower dome rta watercare CoreLogic ocr Must knows bond form RTAA 2019 development financial advisers act covid-19 bond winz worksafe subdivision scotney williams heater renovation beginner investor rent control parry v inglis DTI sale and purchase quiet enjoyment Tribunal case study trespass Q&A rental market structure termination HSWA television Editor's Choice auckland HHS building housing bubble water bill buying investment strategy


Introducing Our Partners
Principal Sponsor - Kris Pedersen Mortgages & Insurance logo Gold Sponsor - Barfoot & Thompson logo Gold Sponsor - CoreLogic logo Property Apprentice logo The Insulation Warehouse logo The Renovation Team logo The New Zealand Property Investors' Federation logo