RSS Feed

CGT - Lunacy much?

Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Capital gains tax

Just this Sunday, Labour's David Cunliffe was on Q+A lambasting a tax regime that hands out tax free capital gains to property speculators as nothing but pure lunacy.  And he would not be wrong. 

Problem is, he is wrong.  In a press release issued yesterday, the New Zealand Property Investors' Federation Executive Officer, Andrew King, rightly pointed out, 'Those who buy and sell property are already taxed on the income from this activity,' whereas the majority of rental property owners are investors not speculators - a distinction that Mr Cunliffe's Labour Party seems to have failed to grasp if their leader's frequent interchange of the two labels is anything to go by.

Property speculators are those who derive a living (i.e. an income) out of selling appreciated assets (i.e. properties) which had increased in capital value.  They are driven by capital gains which are already captured by our income tax regime each time they are made.  In essence, New Zealand already has a capital gains tax in all but name.  

Property investors are driven by reasons that are far more diverse:

  • Providing a passive income stream to supplement our retirement;

  • To have total control over the value of our investments (rather than investing in shares, currencies or finance companies the value of which investors cannot affect); 

  • To invest in an industry (accommodation supply) that continues to have strong demand (housing); 

While any incidental capital gains made throughout would not be un-welcomed, they are only illusionary (because they will be exhausted the moment investors buy back into the market).  

'So,' you wonder, 'where does a CGT leave investors?'  But perhaps more pressingly for me, 'Where does a CGT leave tenants?'  With or without a CGT, demands on the Auckland housing market will always make properties a realistic prospect for investors.  A tax raising scheme designed to dis-incentivise investors will only result in the increased costs be passed on to the tenants who, ironically, are the ordinary Kiwis Mr Cunliffe set out to protect.  

Recent Posts


wins trademe legal market rent Case study election2020 damage LIM bond form Must know cgt buyer's agent Editor's Choice interest limitation legal cost partners clnz positive cash flow extractor fan short term rental Holler robert kiyosaki Market report letting fee shower dome DTI barfoot and thompson housing package debt to income structure wealth creation rta shortland chartered accountants education tenant buying RTAA 2019 bad tenant rent scotney williams property apprentice letting short-term rental early termination lockdown Question and answer reserve bank auckland council Landlording tenancy issues advice auckland will finance property value termination bankruptcy negotiation investor interest only kiwibuild maintenance banking CCC Investment tip unitary plan brightline HHS mortgage lvr How to sublease Property (Relationships) Act rent arrears Investor story election 2017 Must knows ring-fencing twg report investment strategy rta reform trust RBNZ tenancy services trespass property management cat Jeff Bezos khh landlord property ask an expert privacy Q&A principal and interest building HSWA ventilation skill shortage tax winz boarding house sale and purchas government Level 4 financial advisers act speculator rental market management heater retaliatory notice p lab worksafe commerce commission debt enforcement Sponsored post recycling equity watercare relationship heat pump holiday house buying rules Keith Hay Homes sale and purchase television HHGA meth anz Gluckman personal growth equity initio mindset insurance Standards New Zealand Zodiak Management housing affordability capital gain airbnb house prices CoreLogic ocr warren buffett gluckman report nzpif parry v inglis first home buying water bill TCIT subdivision data security smoke alarm tenancy tribunal property maintenance housing bubble Kris Pedersen Mortgages and Insurance income beginner investor market interest deductibility anti-social behaviour asbestos productivity yield covid-19 bond ird business warm up new zealand rent increase Tribunal case study Guest blog development cash-flow rtaa2020 heating minor dwelling insulation rent control quiet enjoyment rental wof apia return off the plan property cycle inspection fixed-term tenancy opes partners re agent renovation inflation meth contamination daikin travel bubble interest rates


Introducing Our Partners
Principal Sponsor - Kris Pedersen Mortgages & Insurance logo Gold Sponsor - Barfoot & Thompson logo Gold Sponsor - CoreLogic logo Property Apprentice logo The Insulation Warehouse logo The Renovation Team logo The New Zealand Property Investors' Federation logo