APIA Blog

RSS Feed

Cause and consequence are two different things

Monday, December 14, 2020

Landlords seeking compensation for damages caused by tenants should take care to prove the cause, not just the consequences, of the damage as VNG RENTALS LIMITED vs Xu [2020] NZTT Auckland 4269426 demonstrates.

 
Facts
  • On or about 2 May 2020, the bathroom of the apartment flooded. Water leaked into the adjoining apartment resulting in an approx $4.5K damage.
  • In an email to the tenants on 2 May 2020, the landlord’s representative stated, “According to the plumber’s advice, it is highly like tenants’ hair stopping the drain up, and which has even led to your neighbor unit 903’s carpet gets wet (sic)”.
  • On or about 5 May 2020, the building manager and contractor attended the site to clean up and repair.
 
The claim

The landlord applied to the Tribunal for compensation on the basis that the tenant had caused the damage and provided the following to support its claim:

  • copy of the invoice from the building manager stating ‘water leakage damage inspection during day off’; 
  • copy of the invoice from carpet cleaning contractor;
  • photographs of the damage; and 
  • record of aforementioned 2 May email to the tenant

Note the landlord did not provide: 

  • copy of plumber’s invoice; nor
  • plumber’s advice of the likely cause of the flooding (i.e. tenant’s hair)

 

The law
The adjudicator summaries the tenant’s obligations vis-à-vis damages to the property under ss 40(2)(a), 41 and 49B of the Residential Tenancies Act thus:

A landlord must prove that the damage to the premises occurred during the tenancy and is more than fair wear and tear. If this is established, to avoid liability, the tenant must prove they did not carelessly or intentionally cause or permit the damage. Tenants are liable for the actions of people at the premises with their permission.

 

Application

The adjudicator considers the ‘[e]vidence as to the cause of the flood is essential to the applicant’s claim’ and is critical of its absence (the landlord had proved that the flooding occurred but not who/what caused the flooding in the first place). Curiously the inference is that the adjudicator had not ruled out fair wear and tear as having caused the flooding. 

 

Outcome

Adjudicator Beaumont dismissed the application criticising the landlord’s evidence as falling short of proving the cause of the flood stating ‘[p]roduction of invoices and photographs are not evidence of the cause of the damage, only of the consequences thereof.’

 

Take-home for landlords
  • Evidence of damage is not the same as evidence of the cause of damage
    • It is one thing to prove that the flooding had occurred, it is another to prove what/who caused the flooding.
  • Any claims alleging the tenant as having caused the damage should be supported by evidence.
    • In this instance, the landlord would have been better served if it had provided pictures of any hair retrieved from the drain and/or report/invoice from the plumber noting clogged hair as the cause of the flooding.        
  • Hearsay evidence for the cause of the damage (i.e. the email of 2 May) is insufficient. If your contractor ever opines on who/what have likely caused damage to the property then make sure he puts that opinion down in writing.

Overall helpfulness scale (Because let's be honest, Tribunal decisions can be a bit of a mess but still, landlords and tenants need all the help we can get!)
⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

 

Recent Posts


Tags

government re agent CCC market warm up new zealand heat pump Zodiak Management trust gluckman report house prices property management rental wof DTI landlord insurance parry v inglis advice rta twg report warren buffett rent control interest only wins management Question and answer airbnb smoke alarm will investment strategy financial advisers act apia buyer's agent covid-19 speculator partners inspection relationship letting fee daikin rental market property cycle business auckland damage nzpif education Level 4 sale and purchas extractor fan shower dome HHS cat mortgage meth skill shortage interest deductibility renovation structure LIM return ring-fencing sublease short-term rental Gluckman winz unitary plan clnz Jeff Bezos insulation robert kiyosaki television TCIT debt to income income property value subdivision quiet enjoyment first home buying election2020 meth contamination lockdown negotiation trespass Case study bad tenant tenancy tribunal maintenance building How to development heating productivity CoreLogic khh off the plan capital gain tenant minor dwelling HSWA Property (Relationships) Act Landlording tenancy issues beginner investor cash-flow housing package finance Keith Hay Homes lvr opes partners recycling equity commerce commission legal bond investor HHGA property apprentice shortland chartered accountants election 2017 water bill yield data security trademe fixed-term tenancy brightline travel bubble termination Editor's Choice scotney williams cgt short term rental tax Investment tip Q&A anti-social behaviour rta reform privacy housing bubble mindset RTAA 2019 RBNZ kiwibuild property maintenance Sponsored post interest rates Holler watercare boarding house early termination reserve bank rent arrears holiday house Tribunal case study sale and purchase worksafe interest limitation retaliatory notice wealth creation ventilation anz legal cost rtaa2020 initio Kris Pedersen Mortgages and Insurance buying rent Must know asbestos Standards New Zealand debt enforcement ird Must knows auckland council ocr personal growth market rent barfoot and thompson bankruptcy Investor story positive cash flow p lab housing affordability ask an expert rent increase Guest blog property banking bond form letting inflation principal and interest equity heater Market report tenancy services buying rules

Archive

Introducing Our Partners
Principal Sponsor - Kris Pedersen Mortgages & Insurance logo Gold Sponsor - Barfoot & Thompson logo Gold Sponsor - CoreLogic logo Property Apprentice logo The Insulation Warehouse logo The Renovation Team logo The New Zealand Property Investors' Federation logo